Ancient underwater caves and ecosystems in Mexico are being destroyed by a train

June 01, 2024

Ancient underwater caves and ecosystems in Mexico are being destroyed by a train

The cave system contains one of the biggest aquifers in Mexico and acts as the region’s main water source, crucial at a time when the nation faces a deepening water crisis.

BY Associated Press

Mexico’s outgoing leader has rapidly built a train system looping around the country’s southern Yucatan Peninsula.

President Andrés Manuel López Obrador promised the more than $30 billion Maya Train project would connect tourist hubs like Cancún and Playa del Carmen to dense jungle and remote archaeological sites, drawing money into long-neglected rural swathes of the country.

Ancient underwater caves and ecosystems in Mexico are being destroyed by a train | DeviceDaily.com
A line of the Mayan Train is built using material dug out from the nearby tropical forest near Playa del Carmen, Mexico; March 1, 2024 [Photo: AP Photo/Rodrigo Abd]

But the crown jewel of the populist’s presidency also runs over one of Mexico’s natural wonders: A fragile system of an estimated 10,000 subterranean caverns, rivers, lakes, and freshwater sinkholes.

As his term comes to an end, Associated Press journalists traveled along a section of that cave network, documenting its destruction.

Ancient underwater caves and ecosystems in Mexico are being destroyed by a train | DeviceDaily.com
Biologist Roberto Rojo, left, collects garbage from a cenote with a volunteer from the group “Cenotes Urbanos,” or Urban Cenotes, a local environmental organization in Playa del Carmen; March 2, 2024. [Photo: AP Photo/Rodrigo Abd]

Built upon a “fragile” and important ecosystem

The cave system contains one of the biggest aquifers in Mexico and acts as the region’s main water source, crucial at a time when the nation faces a deepening water crisis.

The region was once a reef nestled beneath the Caribbean Sea, but changing sea levels pushed Mexico’s southern peninsula out of the ocean as a mass of limestone. Water sculpted the porous stone into caves over the course of millions of years.

Ancient underwater caves and ecosystems in Mexico are being destroyed by a train | DeviceDaily.com
A Mayan Train worker waits for passengers to board in Cancun on March 6, 2024. [Photo: AP Photo/Rodrigo Abd]

It produced the open-face freshwater caverns known as “cenotes” and underground rivers that are in equal parts awe-inspiring and delicate, explained Emiliano Monroy-Ríos, a geologist at Northwestern University studying the region.

“These ecosystems are very, very fragile,” Monroy-Ríos said. “They are building upon a land that is like gruyere cheese, full of caves and cavities of different sizes and at different depths.”

Ancient underwater caves and ecosystems in Mexico are being destroyed by a train | DeviceDaily.com
Engineer Guillermo D. Christy photographs a steel pillar filled with concrete that was installed inside the Aktun Tuyul cave system to support the Maya Train track on the outskirts of Playa del Carmen. [Photo: AP Photo/Rodrigo Abd]

The destruction

The train has sparked criticism by environmentalists and scientists as its construction plowed down millions of trees, a chunk of the largest tropical forest in the Americas after the Amazon.

But the caves rose to the forefront in recent months when experts who have long worked in the caves posted videos of government workers using massive metal drills to bore into the limestone, embedding an estimated 15,000 steel pillars into the caverns.

The pillars were made to elevate the train line, something López Obrador said would protect the ancient underground world, already under threat by mass tourism.

Ancient underwater caves and ecosystems in Mexico are being destroyed by a train | DeviceDaily.com
Tourists wear decorative body paint at a bar on the edge of a cenote in Tulum. [Photo: AP Photo/Rodrigo Abd]

Instead, what the AP documented was destruction.

Across the cave system, stalactites broken off by vibrations from train construction litter the ground like rubble following an earthquake. In other caverns, the concrete filling the pillars has spilled out to coat the limestone ground. Water showed traces of iron pollution by rust coming from the metal.

 

The destruction ripples out to the rest of the ecosystem, the AP found, as the fresh water aquifer connects to Caribbean Sea.

Ancient underwater caves and ecosystems in Mexico are being destroyed by a train | DeviceDaily.com
Railroad tracks extend in front of the windshield of a Maya Train traveling from Cancun to Valladolid, Mexico.[Photo: AP Photo/Rodrigo Abd]

A political promise, but also a political process

López Obrador, who has portrayed himself as a champion of Mexico’s long-forgotten poor, has declared the train “our legacy of development for the southeast of Mexico.”

The populist has fast-tracked construction of the train to try to keep promises to complete it before June elections, something appears all but impossible.

The government has dodged oversight, ignored court orders, employed the Mexican military in its construction and blocked the release of information in the name of “natural security.” In a violation of Mexican law, the administration also didn’t carry out a comprehensive study to assess the potential environmental impacts before starting construction.

The moves he’s made have only deepened his ongoing clashes with the country’s judiciary, further fueling criticisms that his government is undermining democratic institutions.

—By Teresa De Miguel, Megan Janetsky, and Rodrigo Abd, Associated Press

 

Fast Company

(6)