Exclusive: I left Google because of pregnancy discrimination
Over the summer, an anonymous memo by a Google employee on maternity leave made the rounds on an internal message board. In the post, which was eventually leaked to Motherboard, Chelsey Glasson explained that she would not be returning to Google after her leave was up, detailing allegations of pregnancy discrimination and retaliatory behavior. āIām sharing this statement because I hope it informs needed change in how Google handles discrimination, harassment and retaliation,ā she wrote.
Glasson, who has since disclosed her name, shared her first-person account exclusively with Fast Company to help raise awareness of the bias and discrimination faced by pregnant women, even in workplaces with generous leave policies. She has now filed a complaint with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), typically the first step toward pursuing a lawsuit alleging discrimination. After a preliminary investigation, the EEOC will issue a āright to sueā letter if Glassonās case has legs and there are grounds for a discrimination claim. Hers is just one of many such claims: From 1997 to 2011, the EEOC and state employment agencies saw nearly a 50% increase in pregnancy discrimination complaints, well after the introduction of the Pregnancy Discrimination Act in 1978.
But there is a high bar for proving this sort of discrimination in a court of law. Most companies will argue there were sound reasonsāunrelated to the pregnancyāfor the alleged discrimination. To build a strong legal case, the plaintiff has to effectively isolate their pregnancy as the driving force behind their employerās actions.
Bringing a pregnancy discrimination claim against a tech giant like Google, then, is no small task. Though the company has faced other discrimination suitsāsome of which have been settledāGlasson says many lawyers tried to warn her against taking on Google. And those willing to take the case seemed inclined to settle quickly. āI talked to several attorneys about my situation,ā she says, āand the feedback that I got was: āGoogleās going to eat you alive, and theyāre going to use their vast resources to try to discredit you. Your whole life is going to be up for critique.’ā (Google declined to comment for this article.)
In the meantime, Glasson, who was employed in Seattle at the time of the alleged discrimination, is working with Washington state senator Karen Keiser on legislation that extends the statute of limitations for reporting pregnancy discrimination. Right now, to file a complaint with the Washington State Human Rights Commission, you must do so within 180 days of when the discrimination took place. (Some states allow people up to 300 days to file a pregnancy discrimination complaint.) āWhile youāre pregnant and right after youāve had a baby, you have a lot of other things on your plate,ā Glasson says. āSo that window of opportunity to fight pregnancy discrimination just goes by quickly.ā Keiser will introduce the bill in early December for the 2020 legislative session.
Glassonās story, which spans two pregnancies with diverging experiences at a single employer, illustrates that pregnancy discrimination is rarely a tidy narrative and can come from surprising places. These cases are often winding and complicated, in part because they are built on a series of slights that, together, indicate a pattern of unfair treatment. Glassonās experience is no exception. Her account, shared over a series of interviews with supporting documentation, has been edited for space and clarity.
March 2014-March 2018: āI was a really strong performer at the companyā
I was at Google doing user research for a total of five and a half years. I was promoted several times. We go through this process called ācalibration,ā where weāre given a performance score. Two times I received a superb rating, which only the top [3%-5%] of Googlers receive.
I had my [first child] in July 2016, and I was still based out of Mountain View at that time. I decided, while I was on maternity leave, to move my family to Seattle. I started reporting to a new boss at Google, who is very influential in the research department. She was amazingly supportive in my coming back from leave, given some unique factors with my move. She even went so far as to let me work remotely for the first few weeks coming out of leave while we movedāand this is really unheard of at Google.
My boss really respects other high-performing individuals and elevates those folks. In part because of my strong performance, I got to a point where I was promoted into managing a team of six individuals. I had a great relationship with her, and we had a plan for my being promoted yet again [before I got pregnant].
February-April 2018: āMy boss started making some really inappropriate commentsā
There was a mom on my team who had two sets of twins during her time at Google, one set while she was on this team. She had four young children. I noticed that my boss started making some really inappropriate comments like, āI think she might be trying to get pregnant again, and sheās just really overly emotional when pregnant and hard to work with.ā It started small and then very quickly progressed to [comments like]: āI think this person would be much better suited at a lower tier company. What can we do to encourage her to start exploring other options?ā She very clearly was trying to get me to kick this person off the team.
I reached out to HR. Through those conversations with HR, it was disclosed that there was a record of people complaining about my boss. HR didnāt share details other than to say they [were] aware that she [was] doing and saying some inappropriate things and that there was ongoing coaching. They said not to worry about retaliationāthatās strongly discouraged at Google. But [they told me] that my comments might be shared directly with my boss.
June-August 2018: āWork became a war zoneā
After that first conversation with HR, my bossās behavior toward me drastically changed. It was so obvious given we had this beautiful relationship [before]. Work became a war zone. I remember feeling this overwhelming anxiety just walking in the door. Every single project I touched after that point, she vetoed. She [had] one-on-one conversations stating negative things about me to my peers and superiors. The ultimate blow was finding out she was actively interviewing people to replace me, despite our not having any conversations about my leaving the team.
While all of this is happening, I became pregnant. I shared [news of my pregnancy] with my boss, in part because my morning sickness was so bad. The more I [shared with HR and senior management], the worse the retaliation [from my boss] became. I was worried about how the stress was impacting my pregnancy. It became clear that I just needed to remove myself from the abusive environment.
July-September 2018: āI turned down an offer and stayedābut the retaliation continuedā
I started interviewing for other jobs at Google, which is another stressor and like going through a formal interview process. I received a job offer similar in scope and responsibility. I shared with [senior management] and my bossās manager that I planned to leave the team. They both immediately reached out and [told me they wanted me] to stay, [and that my boss was leaving the team] for reasons they couldnāt share.
So I turned down the offer and stayed, but the retaliation continued. A little over a month passed, and then my [bossās manager] calls me into a meeting and tells me [my] boss is not leaving the teamāand, by the way, āyour boss is telling me that youāre not meeting expectations for your role.ā He went through this list of really concerning points of feedback that I hadnāt heard before and felt unfair to me, and it became clear that I was not welcome on the team.
I was like, āIām pregnant. I turned down a job offer because you told me that my boss was leaving and that Iām a valued team member. You put me in a really tough position.ā He just pushed my concerns aside and said, āI bet that role that you were originally offered is still on the table.ā But it wasnāt.
September-October 2018: āIām clearly not being set up for successā
After that, I started the internal interview process all over again. I found an opportunity for a management role that was of lesser responsibilityāmanaging fewer individuals. This is five months before Iām supposed to go on maternity leave. I give notice to my current team.
[My new boss and her boss] wrote this offer letter that said: āGiven timing and future growth considerations, there are a few options to consider related to positioning and structure of Chelseyās role. Plan 1:? Chelsey [joins] as an [individual contributor] now and later manages, when [she] comes back from maternity leave. We prefer this optionā[it] will be low stress for the team. Plan 2:? [Chelsey joins] as a research lead [and manager]. We should be sensitive hereāthe team is very new and still forming, and this plan might rock the boat.ā I knew that wasnāt okay, but I was so traumatized from where I was at and desperate to get out of that situation.
As I start on the new team, they introduce me as a manager. But my boss is pulling me aside saying [I shouldnāt] do anything thatās management-related. Iām clearly not being set up for success.
December 2018: āMy boss was judging and discrediting my situationā
As that was happening, I was diagnosed with a complete placenta previa, which is a serious and unpredictable condition in which your placenta is covering your cervix. What typically happens is that at a certain point in your pregnancy, you start hemorrhaging, and you could really quickly bleed out and die. If you have a bleed, youāre usually hospitalized and put on bed rest.
I shared this with my boss: āHey, Iāve been diagnosed with a complete placenta previa. I canāt travel because I have to stay close to a specific hospital. And I want you to know that if at any point I start bleeding, my leave might start right away, and I could be hospitalized.ā This is where my boss started making inappropriate comments and discrediting my situation. In one meeting, she [basically said], āI just listened to an NPR segment that debunked the benefits of bed rest, and when I was pregnant, I bled a little bit and my doctor put me on bed rest. I ignored what my doctor said, and I actually gave one of the biggest presentations of my career the day before I delivered my son via C-section. And by the wayāweāre not really certain that there will actually be a management role available for you upon returning from maternity leave.ā
I hired an attorney who drafted whatās called a demand letter. I asked Google to help me transfer teams into a role of similar responsibility, conduct an investigation of my [previous] bossās retaliation and her discrimination against a member of my team, and prevent my [previous] boss from having any say in my career trajectory at the company moving forward.
Google refused to comply with those demands. Googleās legal team came back and said they would work with me on a walk-away agreementābasically, that they would pay me to leave the company. I declined to move forward.
January-March 2019: āI was hospitalized for a total of three weeks before my daughter was bornā
[Less than three months before my due date], I emailed my boss letting her know I was processing all the paperwork for leave and that I probably would not return to work. My doctor had encouraged me to take early leave due to āanxiety as acute reaction to exceptional stress.ā
My boss emailed me a few hours later telling me that Iām not meeting expectations for my role. I started having bleeds [after I took leave] and was hospitalized for a total of three weeks before my daughter was born. The day I turned 37 weeks pregnant, I had another bleed, and [my daughter] was delivered.
It was one of the worst, most emotional, scary experiences Iāve been through. And when I should have been focused on myself and my baby, I [was] reaching out to HR and saying, āThis is very clear and blatant discrimination that Iām experiencing.ā
January-April 2019: āHow can you make a claim that thereās no retaliation when you havenāt investigated?ā
[While I was on leave], they finally did start to investigate a piece of my story on the second team, but it felt like a complete joke to me. There was this really awkward meeting scheduled between me and two investigators. I documented my experience along the way, so I shared it with them. They didnāt really ask any questions.
[It wasnāt until after my daughter was born] that they completed the investigation. They basically said, āWell, we talked to your boss about her comments about bed rest, and what we found is that she wasnāt trying to discourage you from listening to your doctors.ā There were several meetings and offsites for managers that I was excluded from. [The investigators] said I wasnāt part of those because there was an administrative error, and I was accidentally left off the invite. This is a really small group of people, so I donāt know how they missed that a fellow manager wasnāt present. [They] also said my boss just did a really poor job of communicating the scope of my new role. Ultimately, they said [they] found no policy violations.
At the end of the conversation, they said [they didnāt want me] to be worried about retaliation, but of course my boss was aware that this investigation occurred. [They] talked to her. [They] recommended I take advantage of free counseling that Google provides if [I had] any concerns about [my] relationship with her.
[In various public statements,] Google has basically said, āWe investigate every reported act of harassment, discrimination, and retaliation.ā And then theyāve also mentioned that in situations where an employee feels like a target, [they] provide support for them to find another home in the company. In my experience both of those statements feel completely false. In the situation with my original boss, for those months when she was retaliating, I was raising my hand over and over and over to my VP, to her boss, and to HR.
May 2019: āMy team gave me a āneeds improvement’ā
We go through the performance review process twice a year at Google, and there was a performance round that closed [while I was on leave]. I had been out of the office the entire calendar year at this point, and in May, my team gave me a āneeds improvement.ā The score was based on my performance [over less than 10 weeks].
Once you receive a āneeds improvementā at Google, that starts the process for your potentially being fired. Youāre usually put on a performance improvement plan. You canāt transfer teams, so I could no longer get out of the unhealthy situation with this team. [It was at this point that] I started interviewing with several companies, because I really wanted to have my next step cemented, so I wasnāt stressing throughout my entire leave.
So Iām home with my daughter, and the first step in interviewing with a lot of tech companies is a phone screen. And some of them were video conferences, so Iām holding my daughterāin some instances sheās cryingāand Iām trying to troubleshoot. Fortunately, everyone was really supportive, but I had to disclose Iām a new mom and taking care of my baby as Iām interviewing. That potentially opens the door for further discrimination.
āThereās this unspoken expectation that youāre just always on and leaning inā
Women experience so many hurdles [in tech]. I think sometimes women will look toward others who they perceive as not having to go through the same hurdles, or maybe they made different life choicesāand I think there can be a lot of judgment and resentment.
Thereās this unspoken expectation in tech that youāre just always on and leaning in. And if work isnāt your number one priority, youāre in this situation where your job is compromised because thereās always someone else who isnāt dealing with those circumstances and can work 70 hours a week. Iām still working hard, but I have very clear boundaries around work-life balance as a parent.
āI have more resources to fight this than most people doā
[Instead of coming back from leave in September, as planned], I decided to leave Google and ended up at Facebook. A day or two after giving my notice, I published the memo. In response to my sharing my story, I received a flood of emails and chats from parents at Google saying they have faced discrimination too.
I have more resources to fight this than most people do. From what Iāve read, most people [facing pregnancy discrimination are] in situations where theyāre leaving their homes. Theyāre having to make decisions because they lost their job. It was awful for me, certainly, but it gets even uglier for people who are not in the position that Iām in.
(20)