Jeb Bush’s ‘13,000 women’s health Clinics’ claim Is Suspect. here is Why.

In one of the most many face-offs that befell all over ultimate night time’s GOP debate, Jeb Bush found himself playing security in opposition to Donald Trump on the problem of women’s well being.

The spat between the 2 candidates started in August, when Bush made some unfortunate remarks about funding women’s well being services. specifically, he mentioned, “I’m no longer sure we want half of a billion dollars for ladies’s well being concerns.” Trump fast capitalized on the gaffe, announcing it could hang-out him the identical means that Mitt Romney’s 47% comment dogged him on the marketing campaign trail.

Bush attempted to clarify his prior statements last evening, claiming that he wouldn’t defund women’s health services altogether—he’d simply dispose of funding for planned Parenthood and reallocate it towards local health clinics.

“There are 13,000 group-based totally organizations that supply well being services and products to ladies, thirteen,000 on this u . s . a .,” Bush said. “i do not imagine that deliberate Parenthood will have to get a penny from the federal govt. those organizations should get funding, simply as I increased funding after I used to be governor of the state.”

That “13,000” figure seems to return from a map that two professional-existence firms, Alliance Defending Freedom and the Charlotte Lozier Institute, launched ultimate month, which confirmed that there are thirteen,540 clinics “offering comprehensive health deal with women” within the usa, compared to 665 deliberate Parenthood locations.

as a minimum one of the most map’s information seem to come back from the centers for Medicare & Medicaid products and services, which is a part of the division of health and Human services. the info include lengthy lists of health clinics in each and every state that supposedly provide women’s well being services to at the least the same stage as planned Parenthood.

however the information don’t damage down what services and products, exactly, these clinics offer. And while most have vague enough names, like “domestic well being heart” or “scientific health center,” as a minimum one—Trinity neighborhood Dental hospital in Weaverville, California—sounds adore it would possibly not supply the more or less ladies’s health services that planned Parenthood shoppers are looking for.

This wouldn’t be the first time that pro-lifers incorporated consultants on a list of planned Parenthood choices: just this month, a federal decide in Louisiana puzzled why dermatologists, audiologoists, and dentists have been on one of these record.

It’s not clear what Alliance Defending Freedom and Charlotte Lozier Institute used to determine whether or not a health facility is supplied to offer sure ladies’s well being services—and even what it defines as girls’s health services and products. but if the Louisiana case is any indicator, voters shouldn’t take Bush’s 13,000 declare at face worth.