See Who Made The 2015 Unicorn Naughty listing
In fast company’s inaugural Unicorn Naughty checklist, we take a look at who in Silicon Valley is getting a lump of coal.
December 22, 2015
Santa isn’t the one one making an inventory and checking it twice. fast firm perused the listing of a hundred and forty four unicorns—startups valued at $1 billion or extra—to peer which Silicon Valley dynamos should unravel to do better in some areas, in response to information from this yr. From miserable working prerequisites to shady subscription scams, these are the unicorns that stumbled in 2015 (and don’t omit to check out the companies who made the nice record!):
Uber
As Uber’s valuation skyrockets, its popularity continues to vacillate. the corporate—whose CEO used to be praised in quick firm’s October cover story as “smart and driven and hungry and also very beneficiant”—used to be often known as “essentially the most ethically challenged firm in Silicon Valley” with the aid of Peter Thiel, the Silicon Valley investor.
Uber started the yr on the fallacious foot with a collection of outrageous New year’s Eve surge worth horror stories. One man was charged $509 to shuttle just 20 miles. Others have been charged for trips they didn’t make and had to endure the corporate’s subpar customer service. In the big apple and Washington, D.C., the corporate is taking warmth for its cars’ “insufficient” wheelchair accessibility. In August, prosecutors published it had failed to identify drivers with earlier felony records. Then it leaked non-public data— including Social safety numbers—for hundreds of drivers. And to prime it all off, the corporate faces a classification-action lawsuit by way of drivers putting forward they’re staff, not independent contractors, and should be entitled to advantages like medical health insurance, cost reimbursements, and guidelines. In a thinly veiled try and stymie the swimsuit, Uber is now requiring drivers to signal a new contract that limits their rights to sue and publishing dubious studies insisting its drivers are completely chuffed in their section-time roles.
All of this leaves clients with conflicting emotions in regards to the Unicorn, which is now price greater than $60 billion and facilitates two million rides on daily basis.
Airbnb
one in every of Airbnb’s biggest transgressions of 2015 was its erroneous response to Proposition F, a piece of law aimed at imposing stricter rules towards quick-time period condo services and products in San Francisco. The pollmeasure failed in November, however no longer earlier than Airbnb unveiled a series of passive aggressive billboards reminding people who Airbnb paid $12 million in resort taxes, a gutsy transfer for a company that avoided paying stated taxes for years. The advertisements rubbed people the fallacious manner, and Airbnb—which quick company has lauded for constructing a “fanatical world community”—later apologized and had them removed. different issues persist, like a scarcity of clarity on how the corporate retains company and hosts protected. And a up to date paper discovered Airbnb hosts incessantly discriminate in opposition to black renters, to which Airbnb replied through announcing it was “in contact with the authors of this find out about and we sit up for a unbroken speak with them.”
Theranos
The blood trying out startup, which quick company named one in all its 10 most innovative companies in health this year and is valued at $9 billion, has spent the last few months defending itself after a Wall boulevard Journal record known as into query the accuracy of its blood assessments. in the report, nameless employees dished on the corporate’s Edison instrument, and medical specialists said its outcomes were infrequently inconsistent with those produced by different machines. Theranos CEO Elizabeth Holmes says the report is inaccurate, and has vowed to show it with the aid of releasing data on its exams to the general public, but has yet to take action, leaving unanswered the question of how just right or dangerous the corporate’s assessments if truth be told are. Theranos can also be butting up against the FDA. rapidly after the WSJ record, an inspection by the agency discovered Theranos had ignored complaints from customers, wondered the corporate’s quality keep an eye on process, and called the vial it uses to assemble blood samples an “uncleared clinical instrument.” In early December, emails bought through the Washington publish advised defense force officials sounded the alarm on Theranos’s exams back in 2012, but the company will have used its comfy relationship with a excessive-ranking ally within the militia to whitewash the complaints.
WeWork
Over the summer season, WeWork, the office coworking house valued at $10 billion, kicked off a labor dispute when it laid off 90% of the janitors who cleaned its new york places of work. The layoffs came quickly after the cleaners, lots of whom are Spanish-speaking immigrants and had been paid as little as $10 an hour, began organizing to enroll in a union for better pay and advantages. WeWork—which in March used to be awarded #15 on quick company’s checklist of Most innovative companies— then hired its own cleansing personnel and required all of them to be expert in English, sending a message that the corporate was once no longer only anti-union, but anti-immigrant, as neatly. After months of protest, the corporate caved to using unionized contractors and stated it would rent from the pool of workers it laid off “each time possible.” people who aren’t re-hired will get severance cost.
FanDuel and DraftKings
the world of delusion sports activities found itself in the spotlight after a DraftKings employee gained $350,000 on rival site FanDuel. The instance sparked allegations of insider trading amongst the two firms. A observation from DraftKings guaranteed “each companies have sturdy insurance policies in location to make certain that workers don’t misuse any data at their disposal,” but the damage was once accomplished. The Justice division and FBI investigated whether or not fantasy sports violates federal legislation by using allowing on-line playing, and each sites stopped working in Nevada after authorities ruled they would want licensing. The fight continues in new york state, the place the lawyer normal sent cease-and-desist letters to the two firms, calling them “the leaders of a huge, multi-billion-greenback scheme supposed to sidestep the regulation and fleece sports activities lovers throughout the united states of america.” Ouch.
sincere Co.
Jessica Alba’s $1.7 billion company prides itself on providing environmentally pleasant and non-toxic alternatives to mainstream merchandise—the whole thing from diapers to detergent. In August, honest Co. faced a wave of complaints from folks claiming its sunscreen left them sunburned. the company answered by using tweaking the lotion’s method to supply better water resistance, but in any other case washed its fingers of the subject, pronouncing the lotion was once examined “with the aid of an impartial 0.33 celebration” in opposition to the FDA’s protocols and the complaints got represented less than half of one % of all of the sunscreen the company had offered. however the problem wouldn’t go away. One month later, honest Co. used to be going through a $5 million type-motion lawsuit over unnatural and ineffective substances in the whole lot from its hand cleaning soap to multi-objective cleaner. the company—whose cofounder Alba was named to fast company’s Most creative folks in trade listing in 2012—insists the allegations are baseless.
Jawbone
in the more and more crowded wearables market, considered one of its key gamers is struggling. Two of Jawbone’s companions sued the corporate for failing to pay its debts. the corporate used to be pressured to lengthen the release of its UP3 instrument for six months because of unexpected issues in looking to make the tool water-proof. The prolong elicited an apology from the corporate’s VP of product administration. In June, Jawbone reduce 20 jobs. Then in November, it laid off 15% of its body of workers and shuttered its NY city place of work as a part of its “technique to create a more streamlined and a success firm.”
Zenefits
for an organization so all in favour of disrupting how workplaces approach human instruments, Zenefits has yet to excellent its personal HR practices. Zenefits, which acts as a kind of middleman between health insurance suppliers and companies, has faced numerous problems this 12 months, including low morale and a excessive turnover fee stemming from neglected earnings pursuits and the accusation that some of its salespeople have been promoting insurance coverage without right kind licensing. It stopped paying staff for unused vacation time, a coverage that took impact in March, but some former workers declare they weren’t paid for collected trip time even before the coverage alternate. Zenefits chalks all of it as much as an “error” in its employee guide and provided payouts to former employees with one caveat: that they signal a unlock waiving any other claims against the company.
Jet.com
Jet.com launched to the public in July providing “membership worth savings on just about the rest you purchase” for a $50 annual membership. Two weeks after launch, it was once in bother with some of its extra-dependent peers. greater than 70 firms—together with Walmart, Macy’s, and Walgreens—claimed the Amazon competitor used to be linking to their internet sites with out permission and providing customers money again for the usage of those links to buy things. As fast firm’s Pavithra Mohan explained, “for competing brands like Amazon, allowing Jet to characteristic their hyperlinks most effective drives additional traffic to Jet (as a result of shoppers return to Jet to spend the loyalty factors they earned with the aid of procuring in other places), which explains why so many brands have requested to be faraway from Jet’s index.” greater than a hundred brand links
have been wiped from the website online because of this. Jet.com is valued at $1.5 billion, with backing from giant investors like Google Ventures and Alibaba.
JustFab
This startup, price $1 billion, lets individuals get discounted garments through subscriptions. however in line with quite a lot of unhappy consumers, the website doesn’t make it clear that “VIP Membership” is a euphemism for “recurring month-to-month subscriptions” and bank card expenses which are onerous to cancel. in line with a Buzzfeed investigation, JustFab accrued more than 1,four hundred complaints with the easier industry Bureau between August of 2012 and September of this year for its shady automatic billing. In November, the corporate announced it was hiring a 3rd-birthday party auditor to appear into its industry practices. The website online’s founders, Adam Goldenberg and Don Ressler, also have connections to one of the vital largest weight reduction scams ever focused via the FTC.
Blue Apron
Meal-package company Blue Apron is likely one of the greatest avid gamers in a growing box of services providing to deliver meals in a box straight away to your door. the issue, though, is those containers aren’t just full of food, they’re additionally full of packaging. despite Blue Apron’s claims that its bags and containers are biodegradable or recyclable, a lot of it inevitably ends up in the trash. but this drawback isn’t limited to Blue Apron; the entire meal-package business is grappling with it. food author Mark Bittman, who lately joined plant-primarily based meal-package startup purple Carrot, wrote in a column for quick company that packaging and accountable food sourcing are his company’s greatest challenges, but that he’s working to handle them. “we’re taking it seriously, and that will be the hardest stuff to crack,” he writes. “I actually hope we are able to say to the larger players on this business, like Blue Apron and Plated and HelloFresh, ‘this can be a popular problem we’ve got, what do we do? persons are making packaging out of mushrooms, do we ship with that kind of stuff?'”
Wanna see who made the good listing? which you could check it out right here.
[source pictures: Sari O’Neal by way of Shutterstock (Unicorn); All sample by way of Shutterstock (Flames)]
(23)