Would Nick Robinson Be better off again On television?
the former BBC political editor is brave to persevere on Radio 4’s lately programme with a broken voice, but how do the listeners feel?
17 Nov 2015
What a disgrace. Nick Robinson ultimately landed his dream job as a presenter on Radio four’s today programme, and he made his debut on Monday morning, just eight months after surgical treatment to get rid of a lung tumour. there may be courage in that, and that you could simplest salute Robinson’s insistence that the show should go on. however radio is an international manufactured from sound.
as a result of we can’t see presenters’ faces, the voice is the whole lot. Even the slightest sandpaper scratchiness registers disproportionately. (I sense, as an example, that my loved Eddie Mair, liquid-larynxed doyen of PM, is at the moment going down with a cold.) And Robinson’s vocal cords have been broken via his operation.
infrequently, all over Monday’s broadcast, it used to be arduous to hearken to the enthusiastic new presenter as a result of there are patches the place Robinson’s voice practically disappears altogether. You felt anxious for him. Is he in pain? Is he going so that you can finish the sentence? Frankly, it was a relief each time today went over to Paris and the comforting, Bournville tones of James Naughtie.
Veteran lately programme presenter James Naughtie picture: REX options
All of that is to assert that the lately listener was once uncomfortable, because of this that you may’t focal point on what is being said.
i feel precisely the same about that Radio four announcer whose voice is so deep and mesmerising he makes the Jungle guide’s Shere Khan sound like Charles Hawtree. You don’t take heed to a phrase the fruity fellow says. The much-mourned newsreader Peter Donaldson confirmed that a really perfect radio voice is at first a chic instrument of conversation: the modulation is the message.
Robinson apologised about his voice to his followers on Twitter.
After Monday’s express, Nick Robinson said to his Twitter followers: “Apologies for croaky first day begin. Been a very long time off.”
I in point of fact hope he gets higher and that the daily voice training works wonders. Robinson is a marvellous journalist, much overlooked as the BBC’s Political Editor.
If the voice doesn’t fortify, however, i’ve an offer. Evan Davis, who made a superbly enticing and sympathetic today presenter, has assumed the Paxman throne on Newsnight, the place he seems lots much less satisfied and secure.
Let Davis return to radio and today and Robinson go to Newsnight, and television, the place vocal shortcomings will also be balanced out via an animated method. i think that’s what they name a happy medium.
the previous BBC political editor is courageous to persevere on Radio four’s lately programme with a damaged voice, however how do the listeners feel?
Telegraph Columnists: daily opinion, editorials and columns from our famous person writers
(37)
